Tolstoy Writes A Photo
In Tolstoy’s novel ‘Resurrection’ a photograph features as a literary device. The basic plot is that the well-born Nekhlyudov, as a young man, seduces a maid, Katusha, in his aunts’ household. She becomes pregnant, is dismissed and spirals downward in society and into prostitution. Ten years later Nekhlyudov is doing jury service at a murder trial and is horrified to see that the defendant is Katusha. He is overcome with remorse since he sees his own acts as the source of her downfall; and all the more so when she is mistakenly convicted and sentenced to hard labour. He decides that he must devote himself to saving her and visits her several times in prison while she awaits transportation to Siberia. It is during one of those visits that he passes her a photograph of them both in a family group taken at his aunts’ estate before the seduction. The photo is a minor device that Tolstoy uses to telescope the action, to summarise what has happened over the past 250 pages. It reminds us of Katusha’s precipitous fall and the invulnerability that Nekhlyudov’s social position confers on him. Yet it is the way the photo functions between the two characters which is most interesting. Nekhlyudov must see it as some sort of talisman, something which will raise her spirits. What a mistake! When he has gone, Katusha looks fondly at this bent and yellowing reminder of happy times but unsurprisingly her thoughts turn bitter when she considers her present fate and she hides the photo away. A single photograph provokes smiles, then frowns then anger. She knows that it was only a decade earlier but it seems to her to be another lifetime. In these minor details Tolstoy seems to isolate two essential elements of the photograph in daily life: it can collapse time and it can provoke great emotion. We are in Barthian territory here, only a good half-century earlier. This is the power of the photo as personal artefact as opposed to its power as dream.